đșđGrettir the Strong vs. Aragorn II, son of Arathorn II (King Elessar Telcontar)đđ
G
|
rettir the Strong and the Lord of the Rings go together like Oreos
and milk. This is because, as multiple scholars have reiterated over the years,
J.R.R. Tolkien drew from Viking sagas to create his enthralling works (https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/c4c5/814378fb305cff5511623c9c3c12ada0db7c.pdf).
And why not? He was a genius linguist, an expert on Old English and Old Norse
literature at Oxford University from 1925 to 1959 who âwent to parties dressed
as a polar bear, chased a neighbor dressed as an axe-wielding Anglo-Saxon warrior,
and was known to hand shopkeepers his false teeth as paymentâ (http://mentalfloss.com/article/59736/10-things-you-might-not-know-about-jrr-tolkien).
If anyone could use Viking culture to tell a good story, it was him!
So, unsurprisingly, a lot of characters in Tolkienâs Lord of the Rings books, and in Peter
Jacksonâs fantastic early 2000s movie trilogy sharing the title, are clearly
similar to certain mythical Viking figures. One example: Aragorn, a brooding
loner fated to become a generous king, is very like his predecessor, the
complicated lead Grettir in his namesake Icelandic saga. Antiheroes from shady
beginnings, they are brothers in more aspects than one, though they come to
drastically different ends.
![]() |
An artist's rendition of Grettir the Strong being a boss:) |
On the most basic level, Grettir and Aragorn each get
pretty rough starts in life. Due to an unfortunate mix of uncontrollable temper
and misunderstood positive intent, Grettir finds himself outlawed in both
Norway and Iceland, which perhaps should be considered a feat in itself (Penguin
Classics: 116-117). As a result, he spends the majority of his time
house-hopping, running from the law under a false moniker (at one point, he
refers to himself as âGestâ) and relying on the hesitant hospitality of family
and friends agreeing to take him in for a short span until he can locate
another place to stay (132). His literary pal Aragorn is equally familiar with
transitory living. Although he is of royal descent (with a ridiculously long
and awesome lifespan of around 140 to 250 years) in Middle-earth and retains
the right to return to the city of Gondor as its king, he begins his tale as a
Ranger (http://lotr.wikia.com/wiki/DĂșnedain).
He is a chieftain of the DĂșnedain people, the remnants of his family, after several
warsâhiding his identity (he is called âStriderâ) and protecting the
communities he wanders through (http://lotr.wikia.com/wiki/Rangers_of_the_North).
Grettir and Aragorn know all too well how it feels to sleep outside in the rain
and gather or hunt breakfast yourself.
An interesting component of Aragornâs long-term
traveling is his personal trepidation that, in addition to having to face the
evil forces that attacked his ancestors in order to be able to reclaim the
throne, he is not worthy of doing so (The
Fellowship of the Ring). Being an heir of Isildur, a former monarch in
Gondor infamous for refusing to destroy a Ring of Power belonging to Sauron,
their worldâs greatest villain, and capable of ruining all things livingâhe had
fallen prey to its magical allureâAragorn is afraid that he will make his
scorned relativeâs mistakes (http://lotr.wikia.com/wiki/Aragorn_II_Elessar).
In that regard, he and Grettir are in outlawry not only externallyâphysically,
visiblyâbut also, in a sense, mentally. Their societies possess negative
perceptions of them that are based in erroneous assumptions: for instance, that
Grettir burned a home full of innocent men on purpose; and, in Aragornâs case,
that he will be as undependable as Isildur was (92).
![]() |
How everyone feels watching Gandalf fall fighting the Balrog;) |
Luckily, they are epic dudes and use their redeeming
qualities to set the record straight. First: innate advantages. Grettir is
stronger than anyone in the history of planet Earth, except possibly the Hulk,
and carries full-grown oxen on his back (114). Aragorn, for his part, is
magically endowed with healing abilities and can revive half-dead warriors (The Return of the King). Second:
fighting prowess. Grettir saves a farm from bandits (48-49). Meanwhile, Aragorn
saves little Hobbits from ghostly Ringwraiths (The Fellowship of the Ring). And, a final third: selfless sacrifice
with attendant near-death experiences. Grettir battles monsters, including an
undead creatureâGlamâand a pair of trolls (85, 150-153). He takes these
challenges to help plagued families and almost dies during them (85, 150).
Aragorn, not to be outdone, pledges himself to a Hobbit whom a rather divided
Middle-earth council selects to undertake a quest to throw the Ring into a pit
of fire in Sauronâs territory and melt it (The
Fellowship of the Ring). Jacksonâs films illustrate two consequent
harrowing moments when a gruesome Orc soldier and a towering troll just about
do him in (The Fellowship of the Ring,
The Return of the King). These heroes
are hardcore.
However, Grettir and Aragorn, for all their similarities, couldnât finish their accounts more differently. Grettir is killed by ignominious sorcery, his head chopped off, and Aragorn, after successfully assisting Frodo in popping that Ring into Mount Doom, takes his kingdom back, marries his independent, gorgeous equestrian master of an Elvish bride, and settles into a peaceful reign (185, The Return of the King). What else would you expect for Grettir, a supposed âsnake,â as opposed to Aragorn, a man ofâhis contrasting name statesââkingly valorâ (68, https://www.quora.com/What-does-the-name-Aragorn-mean)? Maybe itâs Grettirâs selfishnessâhis cruelty to animals, his theftsâthat earns him such a sad death (27, 117). Or maybe, since Glam curses him, he is simply the victim of an unjust fate (85). Either way, he and Aragorn are alike in the legacy that they leave: they are forever known as underdogs everyone saw overcome odds and rescue others, and they are not to be messed with.
However, Grettir and Aragorn, for all their similarities, couldnât finish their accounts more differently. Grettir is killed by ignominious sorcery, his head chopped off, and Aragorn, after successfully assisting Frodo in popping that Ring into Mount Doom, takes his kingdom back, marries his independent, gorgeous equestrian master of an Elvish bride, and settles into a peaceful reign (185, The Return of the King). What else would you expect for Grettir, a supposed âsnake,â as opposed to Aragorn, a man ofâhis contrasting name statesââkingly valorâ (68, https://www.quora.com/What-does-the-name-Aragorn-mean)? Maybe itâs Grettirâs selfishnessâhis cruelty to animals, his theftsâthat earns him such a sad death (27, 117). Or maybe, since Glam curses him, he is simply the victim of an unjust fate (85). Either way, he and Aragorn are alike in the legacy that they leave: they are forever known as underdogs everyone saw overcome odds and rescue others, and they are not to be messed with.
âŠ..........Who is Aragorn? He's like Batman, only better:D
**đđđđđđđđđŹđČđșđčđđž**
No comments:
Post a Comment